As the launch of GTA 6 approaches, why are different publishers now not making an attempt to repeat probably the most profitable online game ever?
They say imitation is the sincerest type of flattery, and that expression is very related for the video games trade. It’s stuffed with copycats – or clones as they’re typically referred to – and whereas the time period can be utilized derogatorily, it’s not essentially a foul factor.
Game of the Year contender Astro Bot was praised for its similarities to Super Mario Galaxy; Yooka-Laylee’s greatest promoting level was how a lot it explicitly copied from Banjo-Kazooie; and with none new Castlevania video games, followers don’t complain when titles like Hollow Knight crib components from Konami’s collection.
One franchise that used to get many imitators was Grand Theft Auto and also you’d assume they might have grown much more commonplace given the collection’ enduring reputation. Yet it appears the alternative has occurred as an alternative, with followers having much less direct alternate options than ever within the greater than decade lengthy anticipate GTA 6.
What is a GTA clone?
First, we have to choose what constitutes as a GTA clone. Fortunately, there’s an entire Wikipedia page devoted to the topic, which highlights the next components:
- Open world atmosphere that may be freely explored
- Gunplay and automobiles
- A sequence of missions to progress the story that contain capturing and/or driving
- Optional side-missions and mini-games
- A storyline that features themes of crime, violence, medication, intercourse, and different mature (probably controversial) subjects
The mid-2000s have been stuffed with such video games, following the discharge of GTA 3, and a few even spawned their very own collection, reminiscent of Mafia, The Getaway, and, after all, Saints Row.
While none of them reached the identical stage of recognition as GTA, they cultivated their very own audiences throughout that decade, providing developer Rockstar some wholesome competitors.
When trying again over the 2010s, although, there are indicators that the effectively was already drying up. That’s to not say GTA clones vanished in a single day. We discovered a fan curated list of them on Reddit, and you’ll see such titles began popping out much less incessantly however by no means solely went away. 2006 alone had eight GTA clones however a decade later in 2016, solely two have been launched.
It does omit some examples, like The Simpsons: Hit & Run and Lego City Undercover, and we contest the inclusion of Cyberpunk 2077 (which has some tough similarities however is an motion role-player in the beginning), besides it’s clear that publishers have been now not making an attempt to compete straight with Rockstar.
This may also be seen in these aforementioned collection that have been poised as GTA’s fundamental competitors. The Mafia collection (which is revealed by GTA mum or dad firm Take-Two) fell off the map after 2016’s Mafia 3 (barring a pair remasters) and is barely now slated to make a comeback with 2025’s Mafia: The Old Country.
The Getaway hasn’t had a brand new entry since 2006 and solely lives on as a TV present that most individuals most likely don’t know is predicated on a online game. Meanwhile, Saints Row is probably going lifeless due to the underwhelming 2022 reboot and closure of developer Volition.
It’s particularly stunning there haven’t been extra blatant copycats in recent times given the lengthy hole between GTA 5 and GTA 6. If something, that was the right alternative to offer determined followers a substitute for chew on, however now GTA 6 is because of come out in 2025 (barring any delays).
Why are there so few GTA clones?
So, what might be the reason for this? The easiest rationalization is that GTA is simply too massive to compete with these days. GTA 5 first got here out in 2013 and even then it was an enormous cash maker, making $1 billion in solely three days.
It didn’t obtain that by luck, or merely good sport design, however largely as a result of it was the most costly online game of all-time, with an estimated price range of over £170 million ($214 million). Rockstar hasn’t stated how a lot GTA 6 is costing them however rumours recommend $2 billion (together with ongoing help and advertising).
Even if that’s not true the truth that it may well’t be discounted out of hand tells you all must learn about why different publishers don’t even attempt to compete. Especially when you think about the massive quantity of proficient employees you’d want and the large time-frame concerned in truly making the sport.
The extra GTA 5 continues to rake in cash, the extra Rockstar has to spend on GTA 6 and the much less in a position everybody else is of constructing a comparable sport.
GTA Online, the multiplayer mode that’s primarily accountable for GTA 5’s longevity, doesn’t simply print cash, its fixed updates make sure that whereas there aren’t any new video games, from Rockstar or anybody else, followers are nonetheless stored engaged with new content material. If it had been much less in style then we’d’ve bought GTA 6 quite a bit sooner than this.
GTA 6 isn’t just an necessary launch for Rockstar and Take-Two, however for the trade as a complete. Grand Theft Auto is considered one of a handful of sport franchises the place even individuals who’ve by no means touched a online game learn about it.
It’s a part of a wider international tradition and a brand new entry means some huge cash stands to be made, which in flip may result in an invigorated curiosity within the wider video games market from each a shopper and investor standpoint.
The trade could love chasing developments however GTA 6 has ascended past that. Trying to experience its coattails with an identical sport dangers solely garnering a fraction of its success and most publishers gained’t be glad with that.
Normally that doesn’t put them off – it definitely hasn’t stopped all of them making an attempt to leap on the reside service sport bandwagon – however the cash and energy required to make a GTA clone on the identical scale as Rockstar Games is simply an excessive amount of.
Technically, somebody like Microsoft or Sony may afford it, however for them it’s not well worth the danger. Not after they already earn cash off each microtransaction in GTA Online.
Why aren’t there extra crime-based video video games?
The logistical rationalization for why there are so few GTA clones is pretty easy however what’s extra puzzling is that so few video games take the extra apparent route of making an attempt to make a crime-themed sport that’s set in the actual world however doesn’t essentially have the dimensions or scope of GTA.
Cops and robbers is among the stalwarts of the playground and but regardless of Rockstar proving how in style the idea nonetheless is, there are only a few video games that take care of the idea or any of the opposite crime-related actions in GTA.
The nominees for The Game Awards 2024 have been lately introduced and of the handfuls of video games included solely two non-indie titles, that weren’t sports activities sims, have been set in the actual world, with no overt fantasy components: Call Of Duty: Black Ops 6 and Like A Dragon: Infinite Wealth (a collection which was at one level in comparison with GTA however is now far too over-the-top to bear any actual resemblance).
Setting a sport in the actual world is just not essentially any dearer than a fantasy setting. There’s nearly no real-world licensing in GTA, to make it appear genuine, so it’s very arduous to know why there aren’t extra makes an attempt to create against the law sport with an identical tone however a smaller scale.
There are video games like Payday, however ignoring the mess that franchise has bought itself into it’s a reasonably minor hit within the grand scale of issues and definitely one thing you’ll be able to think about a giant writer doing higher.
So why aren’t there extra heist video games? More police video games (from each side of the regulation)? More road racing video games? More gang administration titles or drug-running simulators? Or any of the opposite many concepts which GTA touches upon however doesn’t at all times cowl intimately.
To distinguish themselves additional these video games might be extra severe in tone… or extra comedic. They might be based mostly on an present licence (how a few online game model of Heat or Ocean’s Eleven?) or an extension of an present franchise. But it by no means occurs and there’s no signal it ever will.
This is the best puzzle of GTA’s success, to the purpose the place you’ll be able to solely assume publishers really feel something crime associated goes to fail, as a result of folks will at all times desire Rockstar’s video games.
Perhaps they choose that as a result of GTA Online is so profitable there’s no house for an additional crime-based sport and that it’s not possible to pry enoughpeople away from GTA. That does make some quantity of sense however why did it take them two years and innumerable failures to grasp the identical factor about reside service video games?
Why don’t Rockstar make extra video games?
At this level, the one one able to delivering one thing really GTA-like is, funnily sufficient, Rockstar itself. Red Dead Redemption may be very related, together with by way of its stage of success, and there’s nonetheless some demand for a sequel to Bully, aka GTA in class.
But given how necessary GTA is and the way every iteration will get larger and larger, Rockstar is more and more discovering much less and fewer time to work on anything.
After GTA 5, the one wholly new sport it launched was Red Dead Redemption 2. Even after it comes out, GTA 6 will doubtless take up a lot of the studio’s time for a decade or extra and if they’ve time to make anything it’ll most likely simply be Red Dead Redemption 3.
It could also be a stretch to say the period of GTA clones is over, as smaller takes on the idea will at all times exist, whether or not it’s mid-budget AAA video games like the brand new Mafia title or indie titles like 2019’s Shakedown: Hawaii.
But for all intents and functions GTA is just too massive to repeat and as the price of making video games continues to rise that’s solely going to turn into extra true over time. The solely factor which may change the established order is that if GTA 6 isn’t successful, however the possibilities of which might be much more distant than one other writer making a giant price range crime sport.
Email gamecentral@metro.co.uk, depart a remark beneath, follow us on Twitter, and sign-up to our publication.
To submit Inbox letters and Reader’s Features extra simply, with out the necessity to ship an e mail, simply use our Submit Stuff web page right here.
For extra tales like this, verify our Gaming web page.
MORE: GTA 6 gained’t run at 60fps even on the PS5 Pro says knowledgeable
MORE: Another nation bans GTA 5 for encouraging children to commit crimes
MORE: GTA Trilogy dev blasts Rockstar Games for ‘d**ok transfer’ after eradicating credit score
